I didn’t watch NBC’s Heroes when it first started airing. Even though it got a lot of praise, even though I’m a “comic book guy,” and even though people said I was crazy for not watching it… it just didn’t appeal to me.The main thing was, I’ve read hundreds of super-hero stories in thousands of comic books. There’s no way this television series would be able to offer me anything new, other than new characters, and I knew that Hollywood to try and make it “edgy” and “hip” and all that crap. Just give me good comic book. I don’t need a comic book on TV.
And I think that was part of the problem - all the critics were going on about how great and original it was and just ignoring the fact that there are hundreds of great super-hero stories waiting for them at the bookstore. It’s that narrow-minded view that comic books are not a legitimate form of art or entertainment, and that if it’s not on TV it’s not any good, that really pissed me off.
Well, two years later I’ve finally given it a shot.
I enjoyed it more than I thought I would, that’s for sure. It was definitely engaging, well-filmed, and with a couple of exceptions, well-acted. The overall story is pretty simplistic - group of super-powered individuals must come together and save the world - but the best stories are often the simplest ones. As I feared, it’s nothing different from anything I’ve seen before, but that’s not a bad thing.
I know for sure if I’d watched it two years ago, I would have hated it - the hype would have dragged me down. But now that the hype is gone, and I was able to watch it as it stands on its own, I enjoyed it.
The performances, as mentioned, were generally pretty good, especially Masi Oka. With the exception of the always-awful Ali Larter and her furrowed-brow husband, Leonard Roberts, the rest of the cast was also rock solid, with standout performances from Sendhil
Ramamurthy and Jack Coleman. The show also featured some fantastic guest stars, including Eric Roberts, George Takei, Richard Roundtree and Malcom MacDowell.
Some notes on a couple of the main leads, though. First off, Milo Ventimiglia gives a strong performance as Peter Petrelli, but he disappears for long stretches of the second half of the season (more on this later). At first he comes across like you’d want your hero to be - eager to help, believing in himself when others don’t, etc. But then he starts to become whiny and brooding, and he’s barely likeable by the end (that’s not Milo’s fault, it’s the writers). Peter starts out basically as the “main” character and he’s the plot point that drives most of the series. He should have been featured more.
One of my other complaints was that there was a real lack of humour in the series. I don’t want it to be joke-y or campy, but everyone took themselves sooo seriously. Hiro and Ando provided the only comic relief, and even that was a little out of place seeing as how Hiro is the only one to really embrace his powers and responsibility. I hope that going forward, everyone lightens up a little.
Meanwhile the villain of the piece, Zachary Quinto’s Sylar, is a little more troublesome. First of all, while Qunito does a fine job, it’s hard to find him threatening. He’s tall, lanky, a bit socially awkward, with a squeaky voice. Maybe that’s the point - after all I think I just described every famous serial killer - and I wouldn’t want a traditional bombastic, ego-driven super-villain, but still… I don’t know, give him the aforementioned George Takei’s deep baritone voice and he would have been a lot more effective.
As a character, Sylar shows even more weakness. What’s his motivation? Power? To what end? It’s never made clear. Especially at the end when he (SPOILER) steals Ted’s power. He knows Ted is essentially a human bomb. He knows it’ll make him blow up, and he’s already said he doesn’t want to kill “innocents.” Why would he want it? So he can boil his coffee faster?
Unclear motivation for a villain can be a story killer. Remember, most bad guys don’t know they’re evil. There seems to be no reason for Sylar to do what he’s doing other than “he’s evil.” That’s not enough. And if he’s just “insane,” well that’s even more lame.
The second half of the season definitely slowed down and it hurt the show in the end. In the first half, we met everyone and watched the connections between them grow, until the “mini-climax” at the high school, and it worked quite well.
In the second half, everyone just kind of meandered along until the climax. The problem was that we all knew what the climax was - the destruction of New York - so they needed to give us something else to keep our attention until we got there. But they didn’t give us much, and much of what they did give us were nothing more than hints at the larger story (particularly those about Hiro’s father, Nathan’s parents, and Mr. Linderman) that were not resolved. We just kept moving inexorably toward the big bang, without much excitement, and without seeing much of Peter, who really was the anchor in the first part of the season - and who we know plays a big part in the end, seeing as how he’s the bomb.
Thankfully, the climax was pretty good. As far as super-hero fights go, everyone got to play a part, and the battle between Peter and Sylar was well done. And it was great to see Hiro finally get his moment to be a hero - that was a very satisfying conclusion to his journey.
The “sacrifice” of Nathan seems a little hollow, although that’s probably just because I’ve seen the commercials for later episodes and know he’s still alive. Same with Peter of course. Oh well, I suppose that’s my fault and not theirs.
I’d be remiss if I didn’t give a shout-out to Tim Sale’s fantastic illustrations. Sale has long been one of my favourite artists and it’s fantastic that this series gave his art some additional spotlight. As usual he knocked all the illustrations out of the park, and it saddens me that, because Isaac is dead, we probably won’t see too many more.
Overall, I’m glad I waited to give Heroes a shot. Removed from the hype and debate, I enjoyed the first season.
I’ve heard the second season was not as good, but I’ll still give it a shot. I invested enough in the characters to want to see where they go from here; I’ll keep my expectations low and hope that, by the time I’m ready for season three, they’ve learned from whatever mistakes they’ve made, and have got the show onto solid ground.
Tags:
Heroes,
Television